REsource library

Key Items to Negotiate During an M&A Transaction

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are intricate processes that involve far more than just agreeing on a purchase price. For business owners entering the sale process, understanding the many facets of an M&A deal can significantly impact both the outcome of the transaction and their post-sale satisfaction. Negotiation is a fundamental part of this process, and success lies in understanding what to negotiate, how to prioritize, and when to compromise.

Below are some of the most important items that should be carefully negotiated during an M&A transaction:

1. Purchase Price and Deal Structure

While the purchase price often takes center stage, the structure of the deal can be just as important. A $10 million all-cash offer is very different from a $10 million deal that includes earn-outs, seller financing, or stock in the acquiring company.

Key points to negotiate:

• Total purchase price
• Cash at closing
• Earn-out provisions (performance-based payments)
• Equity rollovers or retained ownership
• Contingent payments
• Assumption of debt

Understanding the tax implications and risks of each component is essential. Sellers should work closely with tax advisors to evaluate how different structures affect their net proceeds.

2. Working Capital Adjustments

Most deals include a target level of working capital to ensure the business is handed over in a stable financial state. Negotiating how this target is calculated and what is included in "working capital" is crucial.

Consider:

• Defining what constitutes normal working capital for the business
• How seasonality affects working capital needs
• Timing of the adjustment (pre-closing estimate vs. post-closing true-up)

Disagreements over working capital adjustments post-close can be a common source of tension. Clear documentation and fair benchmarks are key.

3. Reps, Warranties, and Indemnifications

Representations and warranties are assurances the seller makes about the business—its financials, operations, legal status, and more. Buyers rely on these statements to make informed decisions, while sellers want to limit their post-close liability.

Important negotiation points include:

• Scope and survival period of representations and warranties
• Indemnification caps (maximum liability exposure)
• Baskets and deductibles (thresholds for claims)
• Escrow amounts and duration

Limiting post-sale exposure through caps and escrows is a key priority for sellers. Buyers, on the other hand, push for broad protection in case issues surface post-closing.

4. Employment and Consulting Agreements

For many business sales, particularly those involving owner-operated companies, the buyer will want the seller to remain involved for a transition period. This often requires negotiating:

• Employment or consulting agreement terms
• Length of engagement
• Compensation and performance expectations
• Non-compete, non-solicitation, and confidentiality clauses

These agreements can significantly affect the seller’s day-to-day life post-close and should not be overlooked.

5. Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Agreements

Buyers typically require sellers to agree not to compete with the business or solicit employees/customers for a defined period. These clauses protect the buyer’s investment but must be fair and reasonable in scope.

Points to negotiate:

• Duration (typically 2-5 years)
• Geographic scope
• Definition of "competition"

A narrowly tailored agreement can protect the buyer while still allowing the seller flexibility to pursue future ventures.

6. Treatment of Key Employees

If the success of the business relies heavily on key employees, their retention becomes critical. Sellers often advocate for their team, and buyers want assurance that talent will stay on post-acquisition.

Negotiation areas:

• Retention bonuses or incentive packages
• Employment agreements for key staff
• Transition roles and responsibilities

Aligning on how employees will be treated helps preserve continuity and morale during a time of change.

7. Transition Support and Knowledge Transfer

The buyer may need assistance transitioning the business, especially if the seller holds critical institutional knowledge or customer relationships.

Important to negotiate:

• Duration and scope of the transition period
• Availability and support from the seller
• Communication strategies with customers, suppliers, and employees

A clear transition plan helps reduce disruption and facilitates a smoother handoff.

8. Intellectual Property and Data Rights

In today’s market, intellectual property (IP) and data can represent a significant portion of a company’s value. Sellers must ensure proper ownership and transfer of all necessary rights.

Negotiate:

• Assignment of trademarks, patents, copyrights, and trade secrets
• Transfer of software licenses or proprietary systems
• Data privacy and compliance standards (especially if handling customer data)

Ensuring these elements are properly transferred is key to protecting the buyer’s investment and avoiding future legal complications.

9. Contingencies and Closing Conditions

Every deal will include contingencies that must be satisfied before closing. These conditions must be well-defined and mutually agreeable.

Key areas:

• Regulatory approvals (if required)
• Financing conditions (for the buyer)
• Material adverse change (MAC) clauses
• Third-party consents (e.g., from landlords or major customers)

Clarity around contingencies helps ensure that both parties are on the same page and reduces the likelihood of unexpected delays.

10. Post-Close Communication and Branding

Sellers often have a vested interest in how their business’s brand, reputation, and customer relationships are handled post-sale.

Negotiation points may include:

• Use of the seller’s name or likeness
• Announcements to customers and staff
• Ongoing involvement in brand strategy

Maintaining legacy and brand identity is often an emotional aspect of selling a business. Thoughtful negotiation here can preserve goodwill and foster collaboration.

Conclusion

Negotiating an M&A transaction goes far beyond price. It involves aligning on deal terms that reflect not just the financial value of the business, but also the expectations and responsibilities of both parties moving forward. Sellers who understand the full landscape of negotiation items are better equipped to protect their interests and close a deal that aligns with their goals.

With the guidance of experienced M&A advisors, business owners can enter negotiations with clarity, confidence, and a strategic plan. The key is preparation, transparency, and the willingness to find common ground—paving the way for a successful and rewarding transition for everyone involved.